Friday, 14 August 2026

Overview of the European Court’s jurisprudence on human rights in women’s healthcare.


Childbirth and maternity care

  • Ternovszky v Hungary (2010): legal uncertainty around assisted home birth. Violation of Article 8.
  • Hanzelkovi v Czech Republic (2014): a newborn was removed after the mother left hospital early. Violation of Article 8.
  • Konovalova v Russia (2014): medical students were present at a birth without valid consent. Violation of Article 8.
  • Dubská and Krejzová v Czech Republic (Grand Chamber, 2016): restrictions on assisted home birth. No violation.
  • Pojatina v Croatia (2018): home birth. No violation.
  • Kosaitė-Čypienė and Others v Lithuania (2019): home birth. No violation.

Maternal deaths and emergency care

  • Mehmet Şentürk and Bekir Şentürk v Turkey (2013): a pregnant woman was refused emergency treatment for inability to pay. Violation of Article 2.
  • Elena Cojocaru v Romania (2016): a pregnant woman and her baby died after transfer delays. Violation of Article 2.
  • Lopes de Sousa Fernandes v Portugal (Grand Chamber, 2017): the general framework for state responsibility in medical negligence.

Forced sterilisation and reproductive coercion

  • V.C. v Slovakia (2011): a Roma woman was sterilised during a caesarean without consent. Violations of Articles 3 and 8.
  • N.B. v Slovakia (2012) and I.G. and Others v Slovakia (2012): similar facts and findings.
  • G.M. and Others v Moldova (2022): forced abortions and contraception on institutionalised women with intellectual disabilities. Violation of Article 3.

Abortion and reproductive healthcare

  • Tysiąc v Poland (2007): no effective procedure to access a therapeutic abortion. Violation of Article 8.
  • A, B and C v Ireland (Grand Chamber, 2010): a violation for C only, who had no accessible way to establish her eligibility for a lawful abortion.
  • R.R. v Poland (2011): obstructed access to prenatal genetic testing. Violations of Articles 3 and 8.
  • P. and S. v Poland (2012): a pregnant teenager was obstructed from obtaining a lawful abortion. Violations of Articles 3, 5 and 8.
  • Csoma v Romania (2013): inadequate information about the risks of an abortion. Violation of Article 8.
  • Grimmark v Sweden and Steen v Sweden (2020): midwives' conscientious objection claims. Both inadmissible.
  • M.L. v Poland (2023): abortion restrictions for foetal abnormality. Violation of Article 8.

Assisted reproduction

  • Evans v UK (Grand Chamber, 2007): the use of embryos after the partner withdrew consent. No violation.
  • Dickson v UK (Grand Chamber, 2007): a prisoner and his wife were refused artificial insemination. Violation of Article 8.
  • S.H. and Others v Austria (Grand Chamber, 2011): a ban on donor gametes in IVF. No violation.
  • Costa and Pavan v Italy (2012): an inconsistent ban on preimplantation genetic diagnosis. Violation of Article 8.
  • Parrillo v Italy (Grand Chamber, 2015): a ban on donating embryos to research. No violation.

Intimate examinations and detention

  • Juhnke v Turkey (2008): a forced gynaecological examination in custody. Violation of Article 8.
  • Yazgül Yılmaz v Turkey (2011): a virginity test on a girl in detention.
  • Korneykova and Korneykov v Ukraine (2016): a woman was shackled in the maternity ward. Violation of Article 3.

Gender stereotyping in healthcare

  • Carvalho Pinto de Sousa Morais v Portugal (2017): damages for gynaecological negligence were reduced on the basis of age and sex stereotypes. Violation of Articles 14 and 8.

Medical data and confidentiality

  • I v Finland (2008): inadequate protection of a nurse's HIV status in hospital records. Violation of Article 8.
  • L.H. v Latvia (2014): a woman's medical records were collected without safeguards. Violation of Article 8.

Domestic and sexual violence

  • Opuz v Turkey (2009): domestic violence was recognised as gender discrimination.
  • Talpis v Italy (2017), Volodina v Russia (2019) and Kurt v Austria (Grand Chamber, 2021): these developed state duties to assess risk and protect.
  • J.L. v Italy (2021): secondary victimisation in a rape judgment. Violation of Article 8.

Female genital mutilation

  • Collins and Akaziebie v Sweden (2007), Izevbekhai v Ireland (2011) and Omeredo v Austria (2011): asylum claims based on the risk of FGM. All inadmissible, but the Court recognised that FGM would breach Article 3.

Trafficking and sexual exploitation

  • Rantsev v Cyprus and Russia (2010): trafficking falls within Article 4.
  • S.M. v Croatia (Grand Chamber, 2020): forced prostitution, and the duty to investigate it.

Older women, care and climate

  • McDonald v UK (2014): a reduction in an older woman's night-time care. Partial violation of Article 8.
  • Verein KlimaSeniorinnen Schweiz v Switzerland (Grand Chamber, 2024): older women's health and climate inaction. Violation of Article 8.

I can also turn this into a doc you can edit and keep, with space for your own notes on each case.